Ontology evalution Jin

From Tetherless World Wiki

[[:|]], [[:|]], [[:|]], !John, !value, "Data In Your Face": Push Technology in Perspective, "Drop-In" Publishing with the World Wide Web, "Everything Personal, Not Just Business: " Improving User Experience through Rule-Based Service Customization, "Fill-in-the-Form" Programming, "GeoPlot": spatial data mining on video libraries, "I know what you did last summer": query logs and user privacy, "I wish I were over there": Distributed Execution Protocols for Data Definition in R*, "Is It Within My Reach?" - An Agents Perspective, "Kairos": A Web-Based System for Automatic Generation of Weather Forecasts in Two Languages, Greek-English, "Levels of help, levels of delegation and agent modeling", "Logal": Algorithmic Control Structures for Prolog, "More like these": growing entity classes from seeds, "Physical Negation" Integrating Fault Models into the General Diagnostic Engine, "QUESTION-ANSWER" - A Multipurpose Information System, "Reducing" CLASSIC to Practice: Knowledge Representation Theory Meets Reality, "Small-World" Networks of Mobile Robots, "Squeaky Wheel" Optimization, "Tall", "Good", "High" - Compared to What?, "The Committee for Advanced DBMS Function": Third Generation Data Base System Manifesto, 'Closer' representation and reasoning, 'e-science and cyberinfrastructure: a middleware perspective', (515)509-3927, (518)276-4384, (518)276-4426, (518)276-4430, (518)276-4433, (518)276-4464, (518)577-4517, (De)Composition of Situation Calculus Theories, (How) Is AI Impacting Manufacturing?, (Im)possibility of Safe Exchange Mechanism Design, (Low 3112) will move to Winslow after first class, (Updated March 1998)., (e)Proceedings of the Thirtieth International Conference on Very Large Data Bases, Toronto, Canada, August 31 - September 3 2004, (extended abstract), CP-2005 (the Eleventh International Conference on Principles and Practice of Constraint Programming), (mylastname)-at-cs.rpi.edu, *, *** paper retracted by the authors *** (Dynamic Probabilistic Relational Models), , Robotics: State of the Art and Future Challenges , Imperial College Press (2008), ..., /Item-1, /facet: A Browser for Heterogeneous Semantic Web Repositories, /tw.rpi.edu/portal/SummerProgram2009/Student posters, /tw.rpi.edu/portal/SummerProgram2009/Student session 1, and /tw.rpi.edu/portal/SummerProgram2009/Student session 2 … further resultswarning.pngSome part "<nowiki>…</nowiki>" of the query was not understood. Some subquery has no valid condition.

About the evaluation

Following table has the link to tested owl files and their test result using TW OWL Instance Evaluation Service and Pellet

Section 1

owl file	TW OWL Instance Evaluation Result	Pellet Test Result	Comment
Substance.owl	Substance.owl TW Evaluation	Substance.owl Pellet Evaluation	Substance_comment
Units.owl	Units.owl result TW Evaluation	Units.owl Pellet Evaluation	Units_comment
vsto_all.owl	Vsto.owl TW Evaluation	Vsto.owl Pellet Evaluation	No Error/No Warning

Section 2

Following table contain some owl files and their test result and my comment about the result.

Some Issue:

1.Some files have inconsistency test result like "XMLSchema#double != XMLSchema#string" are caused by sciUnit.owl file, if test these files with new sciUnit.owl file I upload, there won't be such problem.

2. There are some files that do not have namespace or entity declared. I try to fix these problems by declare the namespace/entity, but it can't be done unless I know all URL for those entities.

owl file	TW OWL Instance Evaluation Result	Pellet Test Result	Comment	New owl file(file is save as .txt online)
applHazard.owl	no namespace declaration	no namespace declaration	Need to know reference file for entities.(e.g. Phenomena etc.)	No new file
applHumanImpact.ow	no namespace declaration	no namespace declaration	See new File for namespace/entity I Add.	ApplHumanImpact.owl new Result
applInfrastructure.owl	no namespace declaration	no namespace declaration	Need to know reference file for entities.(e.g. material_thing etc.)	No new file
atmo.owl	no namespace declaration	no namespace declaration	Need to know reference file for entities.(e.g. property etc.)	no new file
atmoBoundLayer.owl	file not found	file not found	file not found	file not found
atmoCloud.owl	no namespace declaration	no namespace declaration	Need to know reference file for entities.(e.g. planet etc.)	no new file
atmoDynamics.owl	no namespace declaration	no namespace declaration	Need to know reference file for entities.(e.g. process etc.)	no new file
atmoPrecip.owl	no namespace declaration	no namespace declaration	Need to know reference file for entities.(e.g. property etc.)	no new file
chem.owl	No Error	Consistent: No	XMLSchema#double != XMLSchema#string this is caused by sciUnit.owl see sciUnit.owl comment	No changes been made. Should be no error if using new sciUnit.owl
chemCompound.owl	No Error	Consistent: No	XMLSchema#double != XMLSchema#string this is caused by sciUnit.owl see sciUnit.owl comment	No changes been made. Should be no error if using new sciUnit.owl
chemElement.owl	No Error	No Error	No Error	No Error/No change
chemOrganic.owl	No Error	Consistent: No	XMLSchema#double != XMLSchema#string this is caused by sciUnit.owl see sciUnit.owl comment	No changes been made. Should be no error if using new sciUnit.owl
chemProcess.owl	No Error	Consistent: No	XMLSchema#double != XMLSchema#string this is caused by sciUnit.owl see sciUnit.owl comment	No changes been made. Should be no error if using new sciUnit.owl
chemState.owl	No Error	Consistent: No	XMLSchema#double != XMLSchema#string this is caused by sciUnit.owl see sciUnit.owl comment	No changes been made. Should be no error if using new sciUnit.owl
geol.owl	Load Error	Load Error	miss namespace declaration
geolTectonics.owl	Load Error	Load Error	miss namespce declaration/reference of entity
geolVolcano.owl	Load Error	Load Error	miss namespce declaration/First 2 lines not allowed
math.owl	No Error	No Error	No Error	No Error/No change
mathGeometry.owl	No Error	No Error	No Error	No Error/No change
mathStatistics.owl	No Error	No Error	No Error	No Error/No change
phys.owl	No Error	Consistent: No	XMLSchema#double != XMLSchema#string this is caused by sciUnit.owl see sciUnit.owl comment	No changes been made. Should be no error if using new sciUnit.owl
physRadiation.owl	No Error	Consistent: No	XMLSchema#double != XMLSchema#string this is caused by sciUnit.owl see sciUnit.owl comment	No changes been made. Should be no error if using new sciUnit.owl
physThermo.owl	No Error	Consistent: No	XMLSchema#double != XMLSchema#string this is caused by sciUnit.owl see sciUnit.owl comment	No changes been made. Should be no error if using new sciUnit.owl
sci.owl	No Error	No Error	No Error	No Error/No change
sciUnits.owl	Errors	Consistent: No	SciUnit_comment	New SciUnit.owl
space.owl	No Error/with Warnings	Consistent: No	Space_comment	Space.owl
surfClimate.owl	file not found	file not found	file not found	file not found
surfLandscape.owl	file not found	file not found	file not found	file not found
system.owl	No Error	No Error	No Error	No Error/No change
time.owl	Error	Error	Time_comment	Time.owl

Ontology evalution Jin

From Tetherless World Wiki

About the evaluation

Section 1

Section 2

Views

Personal tools

Tetherless World

links

Internal Pages

reference

Maintenance

Search

Toolbox