Tim Berners Lee once said that although he designed the Web, its full development “was the result of thousands of individuals playing a small part.” He has continued to advocate for a truly open Web, saying the Web “must be able to represent any thought, any datum, any idea that one might have.” But in an age of child pornography, terrorism, and even human trafficking, not to mention identity theft, should all individuals be able to use the Web in any way that they please? What controls, if any, should be in place?