Joshua Taylor Journal Paper Presentation 1
From Semantic Portal Wiki
CSCI 6966 Advanced Semantic Web (Fall 2008)
- syllabus, announcements, presentations
- Lesson 1, Lesson 2, Lesson 3, Lesson 4, Lesson 5, Lesson 6,
- Lesson 7, Lesson 8, Lesson 9, Lesson 10, Lesson 11, Lesson 12, Lesson 13
- Speaker: Joshua Taylor
- Title: Dynamic, automatic, first-order ontology repair by diagnosis of failed plan execution
- Journal: International Journal on Semantic Web and Information Systems, special issue on Ontology Matching
- Date: July 1, 2007
- Authors: Fiona McNeill, Alan Bundy
The paper and full citation information are available from the Edinburgh Research Archive.
Questions
| ID | Question | Name | Answer |
|---|---|---|---|
| Joshua Taylor Journal Paper Presentation 1 GTW 1 | In the motivating example presented in the introduction regarding a money accepted by a slot machine, it is claimed: "New concepts have to be developed: 'coins excluding the new 50p', 'coins that are not too worn to be accepted by this particular machine', 'foreign coins that will fool this machine', etc." This last example, one of discovering what foreign coins can be used in the machine strikes me as an odd one for motivating ontology repair. Might it be misleading to imply that a good outcome is one which subverts the intent (not to mention the *law*) of the thing being used? If a repair can be made to an ontology that appears to satisfy all constraints by is in some sense objectively wrong (against the intention of the system), is this a good thing? Does this "objectively wrong" issue simply fall outside the scope of such an ontology repair system, or is this a legitimate issue of how to discover ground truth regarding a prospective ontology change? | Gregory Todd Williams | |
| Joshua Taylor Journal Paper Presentation 1 Jesse Weaver | In the Further Work section, the authors state that they would like to "investigate its applications to other ontological representations such as OWL." Do you foresee any issues in applying ORS to OWL? If so, could you give an example? | Jesse Weaver |
Attendees
Facts about Joshua Taylor Journal Paper Presentation 1RDF feed
| A | Presentation attended by Tim Lebo + |
| Date | 1 July 2007 + |
| Journal | International Journal on Semantic Web and Information Systems, special issue on Ontology Matching + |
| Paper has author | Fiona McNeill +, and Alan Bundy + |
| Speaker | Joshua A. Taylor + |
| Title of paper | Dynamic, automatic, first-order ontology repair by diagnosis of failed plan execution + |
